Posts Tagged ‘Paul Harding’

My Favorite Fiction I’ve Read in 2023

Another year. Here are my favorite fiction reads of 2023, and as always, fiction is all that really counts.

 

 

‘Glassworks’ by Olivia Wolfgang-Smith – ‘Glassworks’ is an intriguing and endlessly fascinating quirky family saga with one family member of each of four generations involved with working with glass in one form or another. The situations that Olivia Wolfgang-Smith creates for her characters are like no other I have encountered in fiction. They are unique and wildly inventive.

 

‘The Bee Sting’ by Paul Murray – Clocking in at 643 pages, ‘The Bee Sting’ was the longest novel I read this year and the most immersive. This long story of the Irish Barnes family held my interest throughout.

We’re all different, but we all think everybody else is the same, he said. If they taught us that in school, I feel the world would be a much happier place.”

 

‘North Woods’ by Daniel Mason – ‘North Woods’ is the captivating story of a plot of land in western Massachusetts and the people who lived there through the years from colonial times until the near present when it is now advertised as Catamount Acres. What makes ‘North Woods’ a special delight is that the author Daniel Mason’s playful enthusiasm for his material shines through. It is written with a certain esprit with warmth and intensity.

 

‘My Phantoms’ by Gwendoline Riley – Having read two books by Riley this year that were excellent, Gwendoline Riley was my Writer Discovery of the year.

My Phantoms’ is a daughter’s portrait of her mother, a mother she cannot love or even like very much. I found this unsentimental approach to family life entirely refreshing. The author Gwendoline Riley has a gift for getting at the root of her characters’ personalities and for noting the subtle differences between people that might cause them not to get along with each other. Mother love is not an automatic thing.

 

‘Vera’ by Elizabeth von Arnim – ‘Vera’ was inspired by the author’s disastrous second marriage. Here are some words that describe the husband Everard: ruthless, domineering, merciless, cruel, without pity or compassion, malevolent, unrelenting, vindictive, demanding, trying. There is also “his extraordinary capacity for being offended”. This is a dark comedy.

 

‘Time Shelter’ by Georgi Gospdinov – ‘Time Shelter’ won the 2023 International Booker Prize. In the novel, each country in Europe must vote to decide what years of their past they want to return to, which years from the past really glowed for the people in that country.

If Scandinavia couldn’t decide which of its happy periods to choose, Romania was also racked by doubt, but for opposite reasons.”

Time Shelter’ is a thought provoking novel that is quite playful and humorous at the same time.

 

‘Abyss’ by Pilar Quintana – The story in ‘Abyss’ is told by an 8 year-old girl which makes it easy to follow. Children as young as eight can sense the undercurrents that are roiling beneath the surface in their family. They have a front row seat for observing marital discord. What Elena Ferrante did for family and community life in Florence, Italy, Quintana does for family and community life in Cali, Colombia.

 

‘This Other Eden’ by Paul Harding This novel is based on a real incident in United States history. Malaga Island was home to a mixed-race fishing community from the mid-1800s to 1912, when the state of Maine evicted 47 residents from their homes and exhumed and relocated their buried dead. Why is the government so anxious to evict them from their island? Many of the islanders have dark features, so white racism enters into it.

 

‘The Queen of Dirt Island’ by Donal Ryan – There are four main characters in ‘The Queen of Dirt Island’, all of them female and each of them from a different generation.

You only get one life, and no woman should spend any part of it being friends with men. That’s not what men are for.”

The short two-page chapters in this novel made for a quick comfortable read.

 

‘Forbidden Notebook’ by Alba de Cepedes – In ‘Forbidden Notebook’, Valeria Cassati must make entries in her notebook surreptitiously. The other family members must not find out about it, which is not so easy to do with a husband and two college age children. She does not have a room of her own in their small house. Did keeping this forbidden notebook which was hidden from her family cause Valeria to seek out a life of her own, including this forbidden romance with her boss Guido?

 

‘The MANIAC’ by Benjamin Labatut – Here is a fictionalized biography of the real mathematician and scientist John Von Neumann. Von Neumann was one of those eccentric genius types who had difficulty tying his shoes, but came up with the stored-program concept for computers which allows them to do quite a few things these days.

 

‘Harold’ by Stephen Wright – Harold, the seven year-old boy, is in the third grade. Mrs. Yuka is his teacher. Harold’s mind wanders, a lot.

He was in and out of paying attention like someone who was away and occasionally came by to pick up their mail.”

Of course this does present a problem for Mrs. Yuka.

The author Stephen Wright is a quite famous comedian, and ‘Harold’ is filled with the same kind of offbeat humor as Wright’s routines. Like Steven Wright, Harold looks at things from a different angle.

 

That’s all, folks.

 

 

‘This Other Eden’ by Paul Harding – The Apple Islanders

 

‘This Other Eden’ by Paul Harding   (2023) – 221 pages

 

The plot of ‘The Other Eden’, strikingly original as it is, is based on a real incident in the history of the US state of Maine.

Malaga Island … was home to a mixed-race fishing community from the mid-1800s to 1912, when the state of Maine evicted 47 residents from their homes and exhumed and relocated their buried dead. Eight islanders were committed to the Maine School for the Feeble-Minded…

[In 2020], the Maine legislature passed a resolution expressing its “profound regret”.”

In ‘The Other Eden’, we have former slave Benjamin Honey arriving and settling on Apple Island off the coast of Maine with his Irish wife Patience in 1793. By 120 years later, when most of the novel takes place, there are about three dozen people living on the island in primitive conditions. The government of Maine wants to kick them off the island.

A reporter recently accompanied a Governor’s Council to notorious Apple Island, to investigate the little rock’s queer brood of paupers and the squalor in which they live.”

The author Paul Harding does not make the mistake of portraying these residents of the island as being too good to be true. Some of the residents are indeed retarded and have poor vision due to inbreeding. None of them has any formal education, but one woman, Esther, can quote long passages from Shakespeare and the Bible. One teenage boy, Ethan, has an extraordinary talent for drawing. They all live in makeshift houses that somehow protect them from the severe winters. They are humans, beset by all kinds of problems, some of their own making.

The Actual Malaga Islanders who were Evicted in 1912

Why is the government so anxious to evict them from their island? Many of the islanders have dark features, so white racism enters into it. Also the study of eugenics was becoming popular in United States colleges at that time. The Nazis in Germany were believers in eugenics, and we all know how that turned out.

A minister/teacher, Matthew Diamond, comes to the island and sets up classes for the young islanders. Diamond’s faith tells him “all men are brothers, all women his sisters”, but he still feels a “visceral, involuntary repulsion in the presence of a living Negro”. Diamond is well-meaning in his concern for the inhabitants of Apple Island, even though they don’t pay as much heed to his school instruction and sermons as he would like. Meanwhile Diamond’s interest in the island has alerted others on the Maine mainland whose intentions are not so good. Esther Honey, one of the islanders, thought,

Terrible how terribly good intentions turn out every time.”

Diamond takes a special interest in the aspiring young artist Ethan, especially since Ethan could pass for white on the mainland.

Malaga Island today

This is a well-written, imaginative fiction. By the time a reader finishes this novel, he or she will surely believe that Apple Island at that time was ‘The Other Eden’, and that the islanders who were evicted were God’s people.

 

Grade :   A+