“Nocturnes” by Kazuo Ishiguro
‘Nocturne’ is an unusual word. Merriam-Webster defines it as “a work of art dealing with evening or night”.

The climactic point for each of these stories by Kazuo Ishiguro occurs during night time, so these stories are nocturnes. As well, each story concerns itself with music and/or musicians. I think Ishiguro was playing on the musical idea of ‘variations’ when writing these stories, because although each of these stories has a unique setting and plot, there are many similarities between all five stories. They are all written in the first person. The main protagonist in each of these stories is a not-so-young-anymore guy, a journeyman musician who sort of makes a living playing music none too successfully, but music is his life. He meets up with a not-so-young-anymore woman, and hilarity and/or heartbreak ensues.
Kazuo Ishiguro is a stylist. There is a stillness at the center of each of these five stories that makes them compelling. In this book, he is being playful and charming. One quality I greatly enjoy in Ishiguro’s writing is what I call “the unreliable protagonist”. Whenever you read any story or novel by Ishiguro, it will always be in the first person, and you always get the sense that the main protagonist is severely fooling himself. That’s the sense I got from each of these stories.
Nocturnes are also supposed to be pensive and dreamy. Just as a good musician does not play his notes mushy to achieve a dream-like quality, Ishiguro does not get vague or unfocused like so much bad dream fiction does. Instead every scene and detail is precise, note for note.
Here Ishiguro is playful and at ease, not like in some of his novels. Ishiguro’s “Remains of the Day” published in 1989 was a major event in modern literary history. That novel was also written in the first person. I still remember the impact this novel had on me, this story of a head servant who managed his mansion magnificently. This was the first great example of the unreliable protagonist that I had encountered. As the novel progressed, you got the sense that this head servant was deliberately not seeing what was actually going on in the house where the Lord was trying to drum up support for the Nazis among the upper classes of England. This situation reminded me of all the people who work magnificently on their company jobs, but know enough about their company to know it is doing some very rotten things. I also fondly remember the movie, where for once the movie with its leading actors Anthony Hopkins and Emma Thompson got it right.
Ishiguro won the Booker prize for “Remains of the Day” and has been nominated for the Booker three more times since, so when you are reading him you know you are in rarefied quality territory.
“Nocturnes” probably won’t be nominated for a Booker. I don’t think they nominate books of stories, do they? Anyhow this is not an ambitious book. Instead this is a charming way to spend a few evenings with one of our great literary stylists.
Posted by whisperinggums on January 14, 2010 at 12:27 AM
Oh, lovely review Tony, and not significantly different from mine (shameless self-promotion: http://whisperinggums.wordpress.com/2009/12/05/kazuo-ishiguro-nocturnes-five-stories-of-music-and-nightfall/ ) except that you nicely deal with the Nocturnes/music idea in a way that I rather copped out of. I agree with you re Remains of the day – I’ll never forget its impact either. He is a master at managing tone I think…
LikeLike
Posted by anokatony on January 14, 2010 at 12:47 AM
Hi Whisperinggums,
Wow, your comment was quick. I was still doing some last minute editing after publishing, and there was your comment. On re-reading your review, I see you also mention Ishiguro’s ‘unreliable narrator’. Since I use ‘unreliable protagonist’, I wonder if I subconsciously borrowed ‘unreliable’ from you. If so, thank you – it was not intentional. I’ve read five of Ishiguro’s books now, only missing ‘The Unconsoled’ and ”When We Were Orphans’.
LikeLike
Posted by whisperinggums on January 14, 2010 at 4:22 AM
LOL I guess I happened to be on the computer at the time. I think as soon as you publish I get an email! I really would like to read The unconsoled – it gets such mixed reviews.
LikeLike
Posted by Rulette Technique on January 18, 2010 at 9:02 PM
Super Artikel, jetzt muss ich nur noch jemanden finden der Ahnung davon hat und mir das ganze nochmal im Detail erklären kann.
LikeLike
Posted by Tom Cunliffe on February 5, 2010 at 3:26 PM
I enjoyed this book greatly – but then I am a fan of Ishiguro. I think your last sentence sums it up perfectly and I am also content to read it as sheer pleasure rather than as a major reading project
LikeLike
Posted by anokatony on February 5, 2010 at 7:08 PM
Hi Tom,
Yes, I’m a fan of Ishiguro, although I did miss that huge book “The Unconsoled” and “When We Were Orphans”. “Nocturnes” reassured me that Ishiguro has still got it.
LikeLike